Sunday, April 5th, 2026 10:25 pm
Just making notes on this reading of Clan of the Cave Bear.
Clan Fires
Brun (bison)
Ebra
Broud (wooly rhinoceros)
Oga
Brac
Grev
Creb (ursus & roe deer) [dies]
Iza (saiga antelope) [dies]
Ayla (cave lion)
Uba
Durc (wolf)
Grod (brown bear)
Uka
Zoug
Crug
Ika
Borg (boar)
Igra
Dorv [dies]
Droog (aurochs)
Aga
Vorn
Ona (owl)
Groob
Aba
Goov (aurochs)
Ovra (beaver)
In Progress reading notes
There is only a single lean-to.
She only ever calls for/thinks of one person, her mother.
She walked for days before finally collapsing.
My question is: why were they alone, even if there was a man with them she doesn't think of? We know from later books that Others lived near the peninsula, but why was Ayla, her mother, and potentially a mate, all alone out of the sound and sight of a people?
Location wise, despite later books, I would place them as likely part of the Sharamudoi, but she didn't physically match them either.
I swear, the time traveling family makes more sense.
Other than my original theory that Ayla is meant to be a cypher, an insert for modern humanity to observe from, and that is why she has no logical grounding in any culture we see.
A problem with rereading Earth's Children when I try to keep up on hominid discovery and theory, is seeing how vastly underdeveloped Auel made Neanderthal society.
It was the science of the time. She patterned Creb on one of the... Shanidar? Skeletons. But ultimately, her description of them is more accurate to an older evolutionary step by what we know now
Yes, very distracting to read so many animalistic characteristics written into the looks and sounds of the Clan.
The stark gender divide is also distracting, but so plot load bearing. It's not as if we know for certain.
All three of the siblings, Creb & Brun & Iza have herbivore totems. Roe Deer & Bison & Saiga Antelope
Which makes Ayla's Cave Lion, and the use of her as forcible change coming to the clan, even more interesting to me.
And something very interesting to the animal they hunt for the new cave/Broud's manhood hunt? Bison. His father's totem.
Creb was so damn wrong about Broud. And that is the tragedy of this book. BROUD consistently behaved in ways that were very un-Clan, destroying any future they could have made. I actually find it full of despair to realize that he was possessed by such Pride, Wrath, and Uncanny Valley as to bring about the fullness of this story.
Mainly because MANY of the Clan we see deserved so much better.
Creb finding memories of when Clan hunted together, all of the "new" ideas thrown out, Especially Goov's observations on her totem make for an interesting moment. The more I consider the Clan in THIS book versus the Clan in later books, it's easy to think of Brun's clan as being a step back on the chain, and the ones we meet later a step forward from that. Especially the clan man they find in the fourth book, with the different woman.